Munim Technologies

Research/Energy

How DOE's emergency orders keep power plants running

Of 35 Department of Energy 202(c) orders keeping eight US plants open, only the four for one Maryland unit list an application. DOE renewed the rest itself, 0 to 3 days before each order ran out, and courts have decided one challenge in 37.

Nov 16, 2026 · 6 min read

Since May 2025, the US Department of Energy has used section 202(c) of the Federal Power Act to order eight power plants that were due to close to keep running. We put every order, extension and amendment into one table and read DOE's page for each. The record shows a process DOE runs on its own initiative. Of the 35 plant orders, only the 4 for H.A. Wagner Unit 4 list an application, each from the grid operator PJM. The other 31 list none. DOE renewed them on a fixed rhythm: 26 of 27 renewals left no day uncovered, and every one of those was issued 0 to 3 days before the old order expired.

This matters because 202(c) orders are meant for emergencies, and each runs for a fixed term, usually 90 days. A chain of back-to-back renewals turns a short emergency measure into a standing one. Courts have barely reached the question: 37 petitions for review name 14 of the 35 orders, and only one has been decided.

4 of 35

plant orders list an application, all four for Wagner Unit 4, from PJM

26 of 27

plant-order renewals left no day uncovered

141 days

Wagner's lapse, the only gap, 1 January to 21 May 2026

1 of 37

court petitions decided: the D.C. Circuit vacated Order 202-25-3

The question

Under section 202(c), DOE can order a utility or grid operator to generate power during an emergency, either when one applies or on its own motion. Orders are posted one by one on DOE's pages, and litigation over them is spread across dockets in two federal circuits. We asked three things: who asked for each plant order, how renewals are timed, and where the court challenges stand.

What we did

We transcribed every 202(c) order from DOE's public pages, May 2025 to 13 November 2026: 88 rows of plant, event and island orders, each with the dates it is in force. For each of the 35 plant orders we checked whether DOE's page lists an application from the recipient, the plant owner or the grid operator, dated on or before the issue date. For each renewal we computed the days between the new order's issue date and the old order's last day, and any days left uncovered. We joined court petitions from CourtListener's RECAP archive, read on 19 October 2026, to the court's opinion, public litigation trackers and press releases. Summer capacity for each plant comes from EIA-860M via PUDL.

What we found

The eight plants under plant orders total 4,849.9 summer MW, 3,692.9 MW of it coal. J.H. Campbell in Michigan has been under order without an uncovered day since 23 May 2025, through seven orders.

Plant orders and applications, May 2025 to 13 November 2026

PlantStateFuelSummer MWOrdersWith an application
J.H. CampbellMICoal (subbituminous)1,330.570
EddystonePANatural gas760.060
R.M. SchahferINCoal (subbituminous)722.040
CentraliaWACoal (subbituminous)670.040
Stanton Energy CenterFLCoal (bituminous)453.420
CraigCOCoal (subbituminous)427.040
H.A. Wagner (Unit 4)MDDistillate oil397.044 (PJM)
F.B. CulleyINCoal (subbituminous)90.040
All4,849.9354
Summer MW is for the generators the orders cover, from the EIA-860M report before each plant's first order. Sources: doe-202c-orders skills/doe-202c-orders/doe_202c_plant_mw.csv and docs/applications.md.

PJM applied for each Wagner order 0 to 15 days before DOE issued it; those orders let Unit 4 run beyond its environmental run-hour limits. On the pages for the other 31 orders, the only document dated on or before the issue date is DOE's order itself. Later filings come from states, consumer advocates and public interest groups, and sometimes from the owners: Tri-State and Platte River asked for rehearing of the Craig orders.

Renewals arrive just in time. Nine of the 26 continuous renewals were issued on the old order's last day, ten one day before, four two days before and three three days before. None was issued late. Since March 2026, each renewal has started the day after the old order ended. Puerto Rico's island orders follow the same pattern: 10 renewals, 0 to 2 days ahead.

Plant-order renewals by days issued before the old order expired

27 renewals of plant orders. The lapse is Wagner's 202-25-6A, which ended 31 December 2025 and was followed by 202-26-25 on 21 May 2026. Source: doe-202c-orders: data/doe_202c_renewals.csv (lead_days, status)

The one gap is Wagner's. Its 2025 extension ran to 31 December 2025, and DOE's pages list no new PJM application until 21 May 2026, so the unit had no order for 141 days. The only chain that ever lapsed is also the only one that starts with a request. That is one chain, so it describes the record rather than proving a rule; a reading that fits it is that DOE renews the orders it starts itself, while Wagner's relief runs only when PJM asks.

In court, 37 petitions for review challenge orders at seven of the eight plants; ten of them name no order, so their plant is inferred. All are in the D.C. Circuit except Centralia's, in the Ninth. On 11 September 2026 the D.C. Circuit, in Michigan v. Department of Energy, vacated Order 202-25-3, Campbell's first order. That was 414 days after the first petition and 386 days after the order had expired. DOE has petitioned for rehearing; no ruling was found as of 16 November 2026. On 19 October 2026, 21 of the 37 petitions were in abeyance, at least 10 of them by their own orders' terms waiting on the Campbell decision. Every order named in a petition has expired, and the orders now in force have no petition naming them.

What it means

For seven of eight plants, the 202(c) record shows no request from anyone with a stake in running the plant, and a renewal timed to land in the last days of each 90-day term. Judicial review runs on a much slower clock than the orders: by the time a court rules on one order, several successors have taken its place, and a ruling on one order does not change the dates of the others. We publish the tables and a lookup that coding agents can use, so that a question about any plant or order returns its dates, its successor and its case numbers.

We have also stated, in advance, predictions for the orders ending between 17 November and 25 December 2026, including whether any successor will list an application. They will be scored after 28 December 2026 and 1 January 2027.

More research